Ask A Specialist



Dru Saren
, Ph.D.
Behavioral and Education Specialist


Submit A Question


Question:

I have a 16-year-old student with severe learning disabilities. His reading level is approximately lst grade. He is very oppositional and defiant and refuses to do any work. He would much rather sleep, eat his lunch at 9 o'clock in the morning or roll around the room in a chair. The only things that interest him are science, the computer or music. He also talks about drugs and sex and bizarre things like becoming a hit man.

 


Answer:

As a thwarted lit major, I sometimes try to be a novelist and construe the inner thoughts of the students who are most difficult for me. For your student, if I'm him, I'm thinking, "I am such a failure. I can't do anything. People see me as retarded." I see this student's behavior as communicating protest and avoidance, big time. He wants to avoid all school tasks that are hard, boring, or reinforce his negative self-image and do things that feel good (e.g., eating, music) or he's good at (computer, science). He escapes into fantasy that the culture has supplied him - drugs and violence, and very age appropriate preoccupations - sex. So, what can you do? You can't undo years of disappointment or make him able to read like others his age. But you can:

• See his behavior as communication of frustration and despair.
• Not take it personally (it's not about you!).
• Try to establish a personal relationship with him that focuses on his prosocial (rather than antisocial) interests, e.g., science, music.
• Avoid power struggles!!!!!!!!!!!!!
• Tolerate more defiance and oppositionality than you would in a student with fewer educational challenges.

In the classroom, you can:

Consider his need for assistive technology. It sounds as if he is able to understand information at a level significantly higher than his reading ability. Computer technology can allow him to compensate for that discrepancy by reading text to him. Computer technology can also be used to enhance his writing abilities by offering a variety of features to support him in the writing process. Special software programs can: provide assistance with visual organization and outlining; allow him to see and hear the words as he writes, proof his written work auditorily, have words and topic specific vocabulary (e.g., science vocabulary) predicted visually and auditorily on-screen. (See Assistive Technology: AskaSpecialist)

Capitalize on his interest in science and music. Using text to speech software, have him search the Internet about any area of science he likes and visit the website of a favorite music group (that might match his interest in sex too!) http://www.mtv.com/news. Emphasize compensatory strategies, and if he resists remedial reading interventions, respect that for now. Perhaps, when his confidence in himself improves, he will be available again for more traditional instruction.

Our transition specialist, Priscilla Harvell, was consulted and said: "This sounds like a student who needs to be involved in meaningful learning and included in student-focused planning." Since you know his interests, planning and implementation should focus on exploring these areas. Review IDEA's reauthorization '97 Transition requirements. The following web site provides an overview of transition requirements http://www.cde.ca.gov/spbranch/sed/trnsgde.pdf and suggests various strategies that include the student in planning process. The site provides suggestions for planning, preparation and best practices in transition that support meaningful outcomes, and bridges curriculum with Transition requirements. Refer to the following site for suggestions on standard and nonstandard Transition assessment tools: http://www.askaspecialist.ca.gov/archives/2002/transition/April_2002.htm.

The student must be engaged in meaningful academic and career learning based on his interests and abilities. Use an action plan activity that looks at his dream goal and his strengths, challenges, interests, favorites, learning styles, supports and steps to achieving his goal. The student also determines how he can gather and use information at school, in the community relating to his goal. He can then put information in a Portfolio to be shared with others on his team. You can contact Priscilla Harvell at pharvell@dcn-ca.gov for further information on developing and using a Transition Portfolio with your students."


Discussion Home Page
Assistive Technology  Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Behavior School-Related Medical Issues Transition
Assistive Technology Archives  Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Archives   Behavior Archives
School-Related Medical Archives Transition Archives    Diagnostic Center North
Resources and Related Sites    CDE Diagnostic Centers


Questions, comments, corrections send mail to the Webmaster